How to Spot a Great Cybersecurity Hire: Tips for SMB Hiring Managers

How to Spot a Great Cybersecurity Hire: Tips for SMB Hiring Managers

Nowadays, small and medium-sized businesses (SMBs) in America face growing cybersecurity threats—ransomware, phishing, and data breaches are no longer just “big business” problems. Hiring the right cybersecurity professional can be a game-changer, but for SMB hiring managers with limited resources and time, the process can feel overwhelming. At Sectech Solutions, we’ve spent years refining recruitment strategies to connect SMBs with top-tier cybersecurity talent. Here’s our practical advice on spotting a great hire, including key skills to prioritize, red flags to watch for, and a handy checklist to streamline your process.

Key Skills to Look For

When evaluating candidates, focus on a mix of technical expertise and soft skills tailored to the unique needs of an SMB. First, prioritize technical proficiency. Look for hands-on experience with tools like firewalls, intrusion detection systems (IDS), and endpoint security solutions—skills that directly address common SMB vulnerabilities. Familiarity with compliance frameworks (e.g., HIPAA, PCI DSS) is a bonus, especially if your industry demands it.

Next, seek problem-solving ability. Cybersecurity isn’t just about following a playbook; it’s about adapting to new threats. Ask candidates to walk through a real-world scenario—like responding to a phishing attack—and assess their critical thinking. For SMBs, where one person often wears many hats, this adaptability is gold.

Don’t overlook communication skills. Your hire will need to explain complex threats to non-technical staff or leadership. A great candidate can break down jargon into actionable insights—think “Your password’s weak” versus “Here’s why we need multi-factor authentication.” Finally, look for a passion for learning. Cybersecurity evolves fast, and SMBs can’t afford someone who’s stuck in the past. Evidence of recent certifications (e.g., CompTIA Security+, CEH) or participation in Capture-the-Flag (CTF) events signals a proactive mindset.

Red Flags to Avoid

Spotting a great hire also means dodging the wrong ones. One major red flag is over-reliance on credentials. A stack of certifications doesn’t guarantee practical skills—watch out for candidates who can’t demonstrate real-world application. During interviews, ask for specific examples of past challenges they’ve tackled; vague answers are a warning sign.

Another concern is lack of flexibility. SMBs don’t have the luxury of massive IT teams, so a candidate who’s rigid or unwilling to step outside their niche (e.g., “I only do network security”) might not fit. Similarly, steer clear of those with poor communication habits. If they struggle to explain concepts clearly in an interview, they’ll likely frustrate your team later.

Finally, beware of stagnation. A candidate who hasn’t upskilled in years—say, no new training since 2020—may not keep pace with today’s threats. Cybersecurity is a moving target, and SMBs need someone who moves with it.

Practical Tips for SMB Hiring Managers

  • Leverage Skills-Based Assessments: Test candidates with simulations—like configuring a firewall or spotting phishing emails—to see their skills in action.
  • Tap Internal Talent: Your current IT staff might have untapped potential. Offer training to upskill them into cybersecurity roles.
  • Look Beyond Traditional Channels: Job boards are fine, but platforms like Hack The Box or cybersecurity meetups can uncover passionate, hands-on talent.
  • Ask the Right Questions: Try “How would you secure our customer data on a tight budget?” to gauge creativity and pragmatism.

Skip the Guesswork with Sectech Solutions

Hiring the right cybersecurity professional doesn’t have to be a roll of the dice. At SecTech Solutions, we specialize in matching American SMBs with vetted, skilled experts who fit your budget and needs. With our deep industry knowledge and tailored recruitment process, we’ve helped countless businesses build resilient defenses without breaking the bank. Why struggle through endless resumes or risk a bad hire?  

Final Thoughts

For SMB hiring managers, finding a great cybersecurity hire is about balancing technical know-how with practical fit. By focusing on key skills like problem-solving and communication, watching for red flags like inflexibility, and using smart strategies, you can build a stronger, safer business. And if you’d rather leave it to the pros, Sectech Solutions is here to help.

Contact us for more information.